A Teacher Tells a Little Girl with Down Syndrome That Even Makeup Can’t Make Her Beautiful, Unaware That Her Mother Is About to Teach Her a Lesson #5

I went to my daughter’s school determined to make her teacher answer for what she’d said. I expected excuses, maybe an apology. What I didn’t expect was what my own daughter would tell me afterward.

My six-year-old daughter, Victoria, has Down syndrome.

Sending her to first grade was one of the hardest decisions I’d ever made.

Every afternoon, I asked the same questions.

“Did anyone tease you today?”

“No, Mommy.”

“Was everyone nice?”

“Yes!”

“Promise you’d tell me if someone was mean?”

“I promise!”

I had no idea how soon that promise would be tested.

For two wonderful weeks, Victoria came home smiling, showing me drawings and talking about her friends.

***

One afternoon, she came home unusually quiet.

“How was school, sweetheart?”

“Good.”

“Did you play with Lily?”

She nodded.

“What about Emma?”

“She said my shoes were funny.”

I glanced at Victoria’s bright yellow sneakers.

“Funny how?”

“Because nobody else has yellow ones.”

“Did that upset you?”

“A little.”

“Would you rather wear your white shoes tomorrow?”

She looked down. “Maybe.”

“But you love your yellow shoes,” I said.

“I know.”

“Then why not wear them?”

Victoria picked at her shoelace.

“Emma said princesses don’t wear yellow shoes.”

“Well, princesses can wear whatever they want.”

“Even dinosaurs?”

I laughed.

“Especially dinosaurs.”

She smiled, then looked down again.

“Will Emma still play with me?”

I hesitated. “Of course she will, sweetheart.”

“Promise?”

I wanted to promise her that nobody would ever laugh at her again.

Instead, I pointed toward her white sneakers.

“Maybe try these tomorrow. Just until everyone gets to know you better.”

Victoria nodded.

I thought I was protecting her.

I hadn’t noticed what I was asking her to give up.

The next morning, she chose the white pair.

I thought I’d spared her another awkward moment.

I didn’t notice that she’d stopped wearing her favorites.

***

Then came her first school festival.

I’d barely been home an hour when Principal Harris called.

“Mrs. Parker? Victoria’s been crying for twenty minutes. She’s asking for you.”

“Is she hurt?”

“Physically, she’s fine. Could you come?”

I grabbed my keys.

***

When I arrived, children with painted butterflies and flowers were running through the hallway.

Victoria stood outside the principal’s office, crying.

“Mommy!”

I caught her in my arms.

“Sweetheart, what happened?”

She pointed toward a young teacher painting another girl’s cheeks.

“She wouldn’t give me a butterfly.”

“Why not?”

“She said makeup won’t make girls like me pretty.”

My stomach dropped.

“Mommy, am I not pretty? Please don’t lie.”

“You’re beautiful, sweetheart.”

“But she’s a teacher. Teachers don’t lie.”

I looked toward the woman.

She was laughing with another child, apparently unaware of what she’d done.

“Baby, wait in Principal Harris’s office. I’ll be right there.”

“Are we going home?”

“We’re going to the movies. Then ice cream. I promise.”

“With sprinkles?”

“Extra sprinkles.”

Victoria hugged me and hurried inside.

I watched the teacher finish another butterfly.

She’d never met me.

She didn’t know I was Victoria’s mother.

And I intended to keep it that way for a few minutes.

I wanted to hear her explain the rules before she realized she’d already broken them.

But first, I remembered something I’d nearly forgotten about myself.

***

Nine years earlier, I’d made my living painting children’s faces at birthday parties.

At birthday parties, parents often approached me with instructions.

“Make her a princess. It matches her dress.”

“And what does she want?”

“Does it matter?”

“To me, it does.”

I’d always asked every child the same question.

“Who do you want to be today?”

Once, at an expensive birthday party, a little girl climbed into my chair.

“Dragon,” she announced.

“Green or red?”

“Green. With scary teeth!”

Her mother appeared behind her.

“Absolutely not. She’s supposed to be a princess.”

“But Mommy…”

“We paid for professional photographs.”

I glanced at the girl.

“How about we try the dragon first?”

Her mother sighed.

“Fine. But make it cute.”

When I finished, the girl roared.

“Mommy, look! I’m a dragon!”

Another child ran over. “I want one too!”

“Me too!” someone shouted.

Soon, three children had dragons.

The girl’s grin stayed with me for years.

***

Then Victoria was born.

I gradually stopped working parties and eventually became a graphic designer working from home.

I loved my daughter fiercely. Perhaps too fiercely.

Before first grade, I took Victoria shopping.

“Mommy! A dinosaur backpack!”

“Look at this one, sweetheart. All the girls have something similar.”

“But this one has spikes!”

“Wouldn’t you rather have the pretty pink one?”

She hesitated.

“Okay, Mommy.”

I bought matching hair bows, too.

***

When the festival announcement arrived, Victoria showed it to me.

“Lily and Emma want butterflies!”

“Would you like one too?”

She hesitated.

“Maybe.”

“Butterflies are lovely, sweetheart.”

“Okay, Mommy.”

I smiled, certain we’d made the perfect choice.

Standing in that hallway now, I remembered my old notebook.

But there was something more urgent than nostalgia.

I wanted that teacher to explain herself.

***

I returned to Principal Harris’s office.

“Mrs. Parker, is Victoria ready to leave?”

“Almost. First, I’d like you to hear something.”

“What happened?”

“Ms. Collins refused to paint Victoria’s face.”

“Did she explain why?”

“She told my daughter makeup wouldn’t make girls like her pretty.”

Principal Harris frowned.

“That’s a serious allegation.”

“I understand. I’m not asking you to punish someone without hearing her.”

“What are you asking?”

“Could you come to the painting table in about three minutes? Don’t introduce me.”

“Why?”

“I want to ask her a question before she knows whose mother I am.”

Principal Harris considered this.

“All right. But I’ll intervene if necessary.”

“That’s fair.”

Victoria was sitting with the school secretary, looking through a picture book.

“Mommy?”

“Just a few minutes, sweetheart.”

“Then movies?”

“Absolutely.”

I returned to the festival.

The teacher was wiping her brushes.

“Excuse me,” I said pleasantly. “Could you paint a little golden crown on my cheek?”

“On you?”

“Unless you see another thirty-five-year-old princess waiting behind me.”

She laughed.

“Sorry. This station is for children.”

“That’s disappointing. I’ve been practicing my royal wave.”

“Maybe next year.”

“Who makes the rules?”

“The school.”

“And the children choose their own designs?”

“Of course. That’s the whole point.”

“Even if you don’t like their choice?”

She frowned.

“Why wouldn’t I?”

“Just making sure. So you wouldn’t refuse a little girl simply because she looks different?”

“Absolutely not. Every child is welcome here.”

She had no idea she’d contradicted herself.

I smiled.

“That’s interesting. Because a six-year-old girl asked you for a butterfly today. And you told her makeup wouldn’t make girls like her pretty.”

Her smile vanished.

“Who told you that?”

“Does it matter?”

“Children misunderstand things.”

“Then help me understand.”

“I was explaining that appearance isn’t everything.”

“By telling her she wasn’t pretty?”

“I never said those exact words.”

“What did you say?”

She folded her arms. “I told her that face paint doesn’t change how someone looks underneath.”

“Why would a six-year-old need that lesson?”

“She was getting upset.”

“Before or after you refused her?”

The teacher hesitated.

“Look, some children need realistic expectations.”

I felt my fingers tighten around my purse.

“Expectations about what?”

“Victoria kept saying she wanted to look like the other girls. I was trying to explain that a painted butterfly wouldn’t change what makes her different.”

“And you thought telling her she wasn’t pretty would help?”

“I thought it was better than giving her false hope.”

“False hope?” I repeated. “She’s six. She wanted a butterfly.”

“You’re twisting my words.”

“Then explain them to the principal.”

Ms. Collins turned.

“Principal Harris!”

“I heard enough.”

“Nothing inappropriate.”

I turned toward her. “I’m Victoria’s mother.”

Her face changed. “Oh.”

“Yes. Oh.”

“I think there’s been a misunderstanding.”

But I wasn’t finished with her yet.

“Then explain it to both of us.”

She looked toward the principal. “I was trying to help Victoria understand that face paint isn’t important.”

“Then why was she the only girl you refused?”

“She was having trouble following directions.”

“Did you tell her makeup wouldn’t make girls like her pretty?”

Silence.

“Ms. Collins?” Principal Harris asked.

The teacher swallowed. “I may have phrased something poorly.”

“Did you say it?”

“Yes, but I didn’t mean…”

“That’s enough for now,” the principal said.

“Please come to my office.”

“But the painting station…”

“I’ll arrange coverage.”

Ms. Collins looked at me.

“I didn’t intend to hurt your daughter.”

“Then I hope you’ll think carefully about why you did.”

But the damage she’d caused wasn’t over yet.

Principal Harris turned toward me.

“We’ll investigate this properly and follow up with you.”

“That’s all I’m asking. And please don’t make Victoria responsible for comforting her teacher.”

“Understood.”

For one wonderful minute, I believed I’d fixed everything.

Then a little girl started crying.

“Where’s the painting lady?”

“She had to leave,” a staff member explained.

“But I want my butterfly!”

“We’re looking for someone else.”

“Can’t you paint it?”

“I’m afraid not, sweetheart.”

My daughter appeared beside me just as another girl approached.

“Victoria, is the painting lady gone because you cried?”

My daughter froze.

“No, sweetheart,” I said. “The adults needed to make some changes. Victoria didn’t do anything wrong.”

The girl wandered away.

The day still had one surprise left.

Victoria tugged my sleeve.

“Mommy, I didn’t want everyone to lose their butterflies.”

“Oh, honey. None of this is your fault.”

“But they were happy before.”

I looked at the abandoned brushes.

And suddenly remembered what I used to do for a living.

I found Principal Harris.

“I used to paint children’s faces professionally. Would you let me take over?”

Her eyes widened. “Seriously?”

“I even have a new kit in my car.”

“Then you’ve just saved our festival.”

***

Ten minutes later, I was sitting behind the table with fresh paint and clean brushes.

Victoria watched from beside the secretary.

“Come here, sweetheart,” I called. “You’re first.”

She approached slowly.

“I can make you the biggest, prettiest butterfly at this entire festival.”

She shook her head.

“What’s wrong?”

“I don’t want one.”

“Are you worried about Ms. Collins? She’s not coming back to this table.”

Victoria stared at her shoes.

“I don’t want to be pretty anymore, Mommy.”

I put down my brush. “What do you mean?”

“Pretty makes everyone fight.”

“Sweetheart…”

“Teacher said I’m not pretty. You got mad. Now the other kids are sad.”

I pulled a chair beside mine.

Her next words would change everything.

“Listen carefully. You didn’t make anyone fight. An adult said something hurtful, and another adult had to deal with it.”

“But…”

“And you never have to earn kindness by looking a certain way.”

She considered that.

“Can we still go to the movies?”

“Of course.”

“Okay.”

She moved toward the secretary again.

I wanted to follow her.

But a little boy was standing at the table.

“Can you do tigers?”

I smiled.

“I can do a tiger fierce enough to scare your principal.”

He giggled. “Really?”

“Don’t tell her I said that.”

Principal Harris, standing behind him, cleared her throat. “Too late.”

The boy laughed.

I picked up a brush.

“Who do you want to be today?”

“A tiger!”

“Excellent. Stripes or spots?”

“Tigers have stripes!”

“Good. Just checking your qualifications.”

Soon another child approached.

“Can I have a pink butterfly?”

“Absolutely. Sparkly or plain?”

“Sparkly!”

“And you?”

“A robot.”

“Excellent choice. Silver or blue?”

Then Victoria made a request I never saw coming.

***

For twenty minutes, I painted faces while my daughter watched quietly.

A little girl climbed into my chair. “I want a butterfly. Just like Emma’s.”

“Pink or blue?”

She hesitated.

“Emma’s is pink.”

“That wasn’t my question.”

She looked at the paints. “Can I have orange?”

“Absolutely.”

“But Emma might think it’s weird.”

“Then she’ll have something interesting to look at.”

The girl giggled.

When I finished, she ran to her friends.

“Look! I picked orange!”

Victoria watched the girl run off. “Mommy, she didn’t pick pink.”

“No, sweetheart.”

“And her butterfly is still pretty.”

“Very pretty.”

Victoria looked at the paints.

“Can I ask you something?”

“Yes, baby?”

“Can I choose something different?”

I smiled. “Of course.”

“Even if nobody else has it?”

“Especially then.”

She leaned toward my ear.

“I want a green dinosaur.”

I blinked. “A dinosaur?”

“With really big teeth.”

“What happened to your butterfly?”

She twisted her fingers. “I didn’t want a butterfly.”

I stared at her.

“But you said…”

“Because Lily and Emma wanted butterflies. And you said I’d look pretty.”

I remembered the little girl who’d wanted a dragon nine years ago.

Back then, I’d wondered why her mother couldn’t simply let her choose.

And now my own daughter had been afraid to tell me what she wanted.

“I’m sorry, sweetheart.”

“For what?”

“For forgetting to ask what would make you happy.”

Victoria looked down. “I thought you wanted me to like butterflies.”

“Sweetheart, why didn’t you tell me?”

“I didn’t want you to be sad.”

I’d missed something far more important than a butterfly.

“You thought I’d be sad because you wanted a dinosaur?”

She nodded.

“Oh, sweetheart. I want you to tell me what you really like.”

“Even scary things?”

“Especially scary things.”

“And you won’t be sad?”

“Not one bit.”

She tilted her head. “Can I still have my dinosaur?”

I laughed softly. “Absolutely. How scary?”

“VERY scary.”

“Then we’d better give him enormous teeth.”

And that dinosaur was about to start something unexpected.

I painted a bright green dinosaur across her cheek, with crooked eyebrows and a ridiculous little tail.

When I handed her the mirror, she gasped.

“Mommy! HE’S AWESOME!”

“Does he have a name?”

“Mr. Chompy!”

“Of course he does.”

She roared.

A girl standing nearby turned around. “Victoria, what’s that?”

“My dinosaur! His name’s Mr. Chompy!”

The girl leaned closer.

“He’s funny. Can I have one too?”

“Really?” Victoria asked.

“Yeah! But mine needs purple teeth.”

I smiled.

“Coming right up.”

As I started painting, another child approached.

“Can I get a dinosaur too?”

Soon, three children were waiting for their own versions.

Victoria watched them, wide-eyed. “Mommy? They liked my idea?”

“They certainly did, sweetheart.”

She smiled so widely that Mr. Chompy wrinkled.

Victoria studied my face.

“Mommy, what do you want to be?”

I smiled. “How about a queen?”

She grabbed a clean brush.

“Then you need a crown!”

A minute later, a crooked golden crown decorated my cheek.

“There!” she announced. “Now we’re both pretty!”

“We always were, sweetheart.”

I thought that was the best moment of the afternoon.

I was wrong.

***

As I packed my brushes, Victoria approached carrying her jacket.

“Mommy, can I ask something?”

“Anything.”

“Tomorrow, can I bring my dinosaur backpack?”

I stopped.

The backpack.

The one she’d wanted before school started.

The one I’d persuaded her to leave at home because the other children had different ones.

“Of course you can.”

“Even if nobody else has one?”

“Even then.”

She studied me. “Are you sure?”

I knelt beside her.

“I was wrong to make you hide the things you love, sweetheart. I won’t do that again.”

She touched my cheek. “You’re different too, Mommy.”

“Am I?”

“You have paint on your nose.”

I laughed.

As we walked toward the parking lot, Victoria took my hand. “Mommy, can I wear my yellow shoes tomorrow?”

“Of course.”

“Even if Emma laughs?”

“Do you like them?”

“They’re my favorites!”

“Then that’s all that matters.”

She grinned. “And they match my dinosaur backpack!”

For once, I couldn’t wait to see her stand out.

After the movies, we stopped for ice cream.

Principal Harris called.

“Ms. Collins won’t return to class until we’ve reviewed what happened.”

“Thank you.”

“How’s Victoria?”

I watched my daughter admire her dinosaur in the window. “Better than ever.”

“Mommy?” Victoria tugged my sleeve.

“Yes?”

“Am I pretty now?”

“You were always beautiful, sweetheart.”

She smiled.

“Good. Because tomorrow I want to be a purple monster.”

I laughed.

“Then we’ll need purple paint.”

And this time, I didn’t suggest a butterfly.